I also want to correct a few misunderstandings that russell or i or others may have had. Mattey fall, 2005 philosophy 156 denoting in the principles of mathematics thisnotiondenotingliesatthebottomithinkofalltheoriesofsubstance,of the subjectpredicate logic, and of the oppositions between things and ideas, discursive thought and immediate perception. Russells objections to freges theory of sense and reference. Why i am not a christian bertrand russell natural thinker. Russell philosophy 565 philosophy of language prof clare. Russells theory of descriptions university of notre dame. Download russell on denoting university of california, davis book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf. The cambridge companion to bertrand russell, edited by. Thus a phrase is denoting solely in virtue of its form. Russell and frege on singular terms faculty of philosophy. It is used these days in a very loose sense by a great many people. It furthers the universitys objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing worldwide. Russells part, between freges theory and russells earlier views in the principles of mathematics.
The cambridge companion to bertrand russell, edited by nicholas gri. Read online russell on denoting university of california, davis book pdf free download link book now. A secondary occurrence of a denoting phrase may be defined as one in which the phrase occurs in a proposition p which is a mere constituent of the proposition we are considering, and the substitution for the denoting phrase is to be effected in p, and not in the whole proposition concerned. In that sense i suppose there would be christians in all sects. On denoting against denoting gregory landini philosophy 1 university of iowa iowa city, ia 52242, usa email. Thus a statement such as the king of france is bald is provided by russell to exemplify the problem of non referring terms. Russell on meaning and denoting analysis oxford academic. Mathematics in and behind russells logicism, and its reception. The aim of this essay is to give an exposition of the theory of descriptions as it is first set forth by russell in his article on denoting found in mind 1905 each section of this article will be explained in my own words, with the exception of some of the symbolic logic.
Russell on denoting university of california, davis. Russells theory of descriptions in on denoting essay cram. However, special arrangements were made for him to attend the court martial of his friend clifford allen. Oxford university press is a department of the university of oxford. View notes russell from phi 565 at university of kentucky. The text also includes many of russell s own footnotes, cited and annotated below. All content included on our site, such as text, images, digital downloads and other, is the property of its content suppliers and protected by us and international laws. A definite description such as the king of france can fail to find a referent if there is, in fact no king of france. By a denoting phrase i mean a phrase such as any one of the following.
On denoting university of washington book pdf free download link book now. Bertrand arthur william russell,18 may 18722 february 1970 was a briti. Blackburncode on russells crit of frege in on denote. Perhaps it would be as well, first of all, to try to make out what one means by the word christian. An inquiry into meaning and truth examines the relation between our language and the world. On denoting, bya denoting phrase i mean a phrase such as any one of the following. Why i am not impressed by bertrand russells why i am not.
In on denoting from 1905, which you can read here, russell argues that its not necessary to have entities like senses as frege does. Russells theory of descriptions in on denoting introduction the aim of this essay is to give an exposition of the theory of descriptions as it is first set forth by russell in his article on denoting found in mind 1905. It is useless on its own, but very handy if it is a part of a wider union of utterances. The analysis of mind by bertrand russell 1921 muirhead library of philosophy an admirable statement of the aims of the library of philosophy was provided by the first editor, the late professor j. On reading on denoting russell is basically translating what he regards as problematic english sentences into a first order language, and then proposing an analysis using the tools of first order logic. All books are in clear copy here, and all files are secure so dont worry about it. For russell, a denoting phrase such as a man is not a singular utterance or thought. Puzzles freges puzzle substitutivity salva veritate. The phrase denoting complex occupies a prominent position in russells argument against frege see above. Education and the social order by bertrand russell in chm, djvu, fb3 download ebook. Reading on denoting on its centenary david kaplan1 my project is primarily expository and context setting.
Although i flag a few issues in my own voice, i am trying, on the whole, to present my discussion and analysis in a. He was led to think he was since russell, like aristotle, so often distorts others thought into his own mould,5 geach advises the reader of on denoting to ignore the. Pathways to philosophy isfp associate award justin. Russells 1905 theory of denoting comparison of russells and freges theories the material in the lectures is covered in slightly more detail in some draft chapters. Each section of this article will be explained in my own words, with the exception of some of the symbolic logic. About on denoting text via this link, graciously provided by the university of michigan. I argue in this paper, based on close textual analysis, that russell s notorious grays elegy argument in on denoting is completely invalid, and founded on notational confusion. Having trouble understanding russells criticism of frege. Why i am not impressed by bertrand russells why i am not a christian from a talk given to the odfr at carnegiemellon university by david snoke in the spirit of this forum, let me start by saying a few remarks about myself and my personal journey to faith. On denoting university of washington book pdf free download link or read online here in pdf.
Russell s principle argument against frege is russell s discussion of grays elegy, which is su ciently confusing that it merits a separate handout. Some people mean no more by it than a person who attempts to live a good life. The garrison commander of newhaven wrote bertrand russell the following reply. Russell introduces the phrase in a way which indicates that a denoting complex is identical with a sense, thus denoting complex just provides an alternative way of speaking, but he then goes on to speak as though a denoting complex had a sensea view which is inconsistent with his explanation of the phrase. Bertrand russell an inquary into meaning and truth.
It is ed atch object s do o tsubsist, u tss ey re e d to b e s. Education and the social order by bertrand russell pdf. In praise of idleness bertrand russell like most of my generation, i was brought up on the saying. It was published in the philosophy journal mind in 1905. Russell gives us an example by showing how denoting phrases can only exist in a much larger framework. There are three main motivations for the theory of descriptions. Being a highly virtuous child, i believed all that i was told, and acquired a conscience which has kept. Bertrand russell a history of western philosophy and its connection with political and social circumstances from the earliest times to the present day simon and schuster, new york all rights reserved including the right of reproduction in whole or in part in any form copyright, 1945, by bertrand russell published by simon and schuster, inc. A key point of transition between our frege episode and quine episode is russells theory of definite descriptions. In it, russell introduces and advocates his theory of denoting phrases, according to which definite descriptions and other denoting phrases. In on denoting, russell criticizes freges sensereference distinction by bringing up two examples the first one concerns the sentence the present king of france is bald, which i understand.
As we noted in section 3, one of the key motivations for russell s theory of descriptions was the idea that it could ameliorate the problem of non denoting expressionsexpressions like the golden mountain, and the present king of france. Searle claims that russells use of the phrase is slipshod, but that it stands for the meaning of a denoting phrase. Here he was denied access to the newhaven special military area. Muirhead, in his description of the original programme printed in erdmanns history of philosophy under the date 1890. Russells theory of descriptions phil 83104 september 5, 2011 1. Russell attempts to establish two fundamental points.
1596 1593 1003 1346 630 552 193 167 978 1614 46 339 1424 1183 513 964 1355 511 561 1314 1247 1159 179 1234 442 1187 1391 1440 109 1296 1183 1522 1521 965 1442 1668 703 634 714 712 877 502 49 740 948 1079 279 1070 173